Keats Insurance Agencies – Florida NY

At the Keats Agency – Florida, NY you can expect smart, efficient, client-focused insurance advice and solutions. We are conveniently located on RT-17A in the center of Florida enabling us to serve all of Orange County, the Hudson Valley and beyond. We live, play and support our local community with good old home town values and have for many years. We have a full complement of top rated insurance carriers to offer you choice and flexibility. Associate Agent Donna Penwarden leads our team with her vast experience, knowledge and care.

‘We know Farms’ We are the Farm Specialists for New York State and have on staff a Master Certified Farm Agent and a farm service team.

Whether it’s your need for Auto, House, Farm or Business Insurance, we believe in connecting you with affordable protection you need and want. All of our services are provided with personal, prompt and professional attention you’d expect from an insurance agency with deep roots. Keats Agency – Florida, NY is your local friend in the insurance business.

Meet Your Team

Languages Spoken: English, Spanish


John Keats - Vice President

Learn More

John has been overseeing the sales and operations of The Keats Agency since 2005. Starting in the insurance industry in 1987 and John’s career path had him wearing many hats prior to coming to the Keats Agency, with the most recent being the Director of Support / Customer Service with a national chain. John’s career experience and his service to our country in the US Marine Corp, provides him the tools to effectively lead The Keats Agency on a successful path. John’s theme is that ‘success is a journey and not a destination’ and he lives that daily.

John and his beautiful wife Deanna, live in Sullivan County NY with their two pups; Guess and Karma. Their son Jonathan is a graduate from SUNY at Albany and is currently pursuing successful path of his own.

Donna Penwarden - Associate Agent

Learn More

Donna is licensed in Property & Casualty and Life Insurance. She holds Masters of Business Administration from Long Island University. Donna has been in the insurance field since 1995.

Donna works in our sunny Florida NY office and living in nearby Goshen with her family. Donna loves being part of the Florida and Goshen communities and is very much involved in the schools.


Kayla Sullivan - Licensed CSR

Learn More

Kayla Sullivan has been with Keats Agency since 2006

Keats Agencies – Florida, NY in the Community

Hudson Valley Hunger Fight
Boy Scouts USA
Florida Chamber of Commerce
NYS Farm Bureau
Cornell Cooperative Extension
Florida Historical Society

Get a Free Quote Today!

Ask us a question.

No Obligation

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Phone Number? (required)

Best time for contact?

Line of business? (required)


Our Address

Keats Insurance Agencies – Florida NY

Address: 103 N Main St, Florida, NY 10921
Phone: (845) 618-4000

Find Us Easily